01 Check what a paper’s result supports
“The held-out benchmark tests generalization: it is never shown to the AAR” (opens the source)
Check which evaluation items overlap with training before making a generalization claim.
Explain what an experiment shows, what it leaves open and which result would change your mind.
Practice a research discussion“The held-out benchmark tests generalization: it is never shown to the AAR” (opens the source)
Check which evaluation items overlap with training before making a generalization claim.
“trained on the same base model and underlying data, but reasons in English.” (opens the source)
Keep the base model, budget and scoring fixed while you change one factor.
Apply both scoring rules to the saved outputs and see what follows the rule.
Use the remaining budget for a comparison that isolates your question.
“You make clear what changed and why the evidence supports it” (opens the source)
Explain what the pilot shows and what the next runs would test.
Keep the conclusion within the benchmark, interval and tolerance you set.
Show how the final comparison supports the paper’s specific claim.
Last reviewed Nov 11, 2026